Are hydrogen vehicles worth the cost of hydrogen?

Are hydrogen vehicles worth the cost of hydrogen?

You don't see many hydrogen-powered vehicles out there. But, if it can be produced cheaply, hydrogen's stock will rise.

In today’s high-priced-gasoline world, you hear a lot about two strong contenders as viable ways to eliminate – or at least severely lessen – the U.S.’s reliance on oil: battery-electric and hydrogen. But, of these two, hydrogen seems to have the most question marks associated with it.

On the one hand, hydrogen has a lot of plusses in the pros & cons list. It’s renewable and readily available – I mean, it extractable from water. It’s also a relatively clean energy source, depending on the extraction process, when compared to fuels like gasoline. Hydrogen fuel cells also have some of the benefits of battery electric, like emitting no noise, and even have much faster charging times than batteries on the market today.

But, here’s the big, giant stick in the mud when it comes to hydrogen: Cost. The problem is that hydrogen has less energy per unit volume than other fuels. This means the entire supply chain – transportation, storage, delivery, and everything in between – is typically more expensive on a per gasoline gallon equivalency.

Because of this, while hydrogen cars and trucks certainly do exist, their use cases are few and far between as the technology stands today. But, there are a lot of very smart companies out there pushing the envelope and finding ways to make hydrogen both more viable and cheaper.

Here’s a great viability use-case: Combining battery electric and hydrogen into one vehicle, like the UK’s Tevva, and its fuel cell-supported heavy goods vehicle. First off, it’s an electric vehicle, no qualms about that, but it uses a hydrogen fuel cell system to top up the battery, acting more like a range extender than the sole source of range.

Tevva isn’t the only one with this idea, following in the footsteps of truck OEM legends like Daimler Trucks and Volvo Trucks, who are both working on similar hydrogen-based fuel cell electric vehicle ideas in their respective businesses.

Here’s another idea: Just make hydrogen cheaper.

Researchers are coming at this idea from lots of different directions, and one of the exciting ones comes from a group of Australian nanotechnology researchers at Deakin University. They say they have made a breakthrough process that offers a novel way to separate, store and transport huge amounts of the gas safely, with no waste.

Now, traditional oil refinery methods use a high-energy “cryogenic distillation” process. Instead, it’s used to separate crude oil into the different gases used by consumers, like gasoline or household gas. This process makes up – get this – 15% of the world’s energy use, the researchers say.

They add they have a completely different way of separating and storing gases, which uses a tiny fraction of the energy and creates zero waste. They use an ingredient called boron nitride powder, which is great for absorbing substances because it is so small, yet has a large amount of surface area for absorption. Once absorbed into this material, the gas can be transported and, then, when the gas is needed, the powder can be heated in a vacuum to release the gas unchanged.

Hydrogen is a huge business, so if this method or any one of a dozen others should catch on as an effective production solution, we may be seeing more hydrogen-powered vehicles on our roads sooner than we might expect.

Now, one thing to mention about hydrogen before we end here: I mentioned before that hydrogen is renewable and readily available, and is clean compared to gasoline. That’s all true in a general sense, but it’s important to mention there are a lot of ways to produce hydrogen, and some are cleaner and some are cheaper than others.

These hydrogen production processes are coded by color, and there are nine of them. The three you probably hear about most often is green, grey and blue hydrogen, and these tend to be the most common codes thrown around in the automotive space.

Green hydrogen is produced through water electrolysis with renewable electricity, like wind and solar. Grey is essentially the exact opposite, producing hydrogen via fossil fuels and releasing CO2 into the atmosphere. Blue hydrogen is somewhere in the middle – it’s sourced from fossil fuels, but the CO2 is captured and stored someplace, so it’s generally considered to be carbon neutral.

While these classifications don’t really matter when it comes to the end product, they do matter in terms of hydrogen’s cost and decarbonization efforts. As hydrogen finds more ways to become useful by businesses and consumers, you’re likely going to hear these colors and other less common hydrogen-related ones thrown around a lot, like red, brown and even turquoise. And, if you care about the cost of refueling your fuel cell or its effect on your environment, you’ll likely become attached to one.

Want more EV Impact Show? Click here.

You May Also Like

Are EV tires all marketing hype?

Tire manufacturers are taking different approaches to how they are marketing EV tires.


Tires wear faster on EVs as a result of the added weight of the vehicle and the near-instant torque provided by the all-electric drivetrain. Can tiremakers really combat this by tweaking the compounding or materials and putting an EV stamp on the sidewall of the tire?

The short answer: Yes! The long answer: Yes... but maybe we're asking the wrong question.

Is Ford’s EV plan working?

One of Ford’s biggest opportunities for growth and value creation lands in EV sales.

This is the No. 1 challenge facing EV adoption

Despite EV adoption rates growing, there’s still a lot to learn. Are the top consumer concerns warranted?

The EV battery materials sourcing problem

What innovations could help lessen the detrimental impacts stemming from EV battery manufacturing?

Why are so many autonomous vehicles also EVs?

There’s a really good reason why manufacturers generally choose all-electric powertrains for their autonomous creations.


Other Posts

MIT EV team creates open-source, hydrogen-fuel-cell motorcycle

The DM15 fuel cell module is already in use in several applications, including drones, material handling, and backup power.

Carrier Transicold debuts Supra eCool truck refrigeration series

Commercial availability in North America is slated for later this year.

Autocar announces ‘Power Up’ program to finance electric fleets

The “Power Up” program is a vehicle financing solution that is designed to help customers grow their electric fleets.

Walmart receives first in fleet of electric terminal tractors

Every E-ACTT can work a 22-hour shift and is capable of recharging in as little as three hours.