Tesla Autopilot: The challenges of autonomy

Tesla Autopilot: The challenges of autonomy

Tesla Autopilot is actually only a level 2 AV system; it is not a self-driving car, and a human always needs to pay attention to the road.

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) has begun an investigation into Tesla and its self-driving car crashes, bringing the challenges of autonomous vehicle adoption to the spotlight. The NHTSA has identified 11 crashes of particular concern, where the vehicle was operating in an autopilot mode prior to the collision and the driver was sometimes completely distracted from the task of driving.

Tesla’s vehicles boast ‘Full-Self-Driving’ (FSD), but current regulations do not allow for fully autonomous vehicles on the road. To find out what’s happening, IDTechEx recently analyzed regulations governing autonomous cars in its latest report “Autonomous Cars, Robotaxis & Sensors 2022-2042.”

The term Autonomous Vehicle (AV) conjures images of cars running around independently, devoid of human input. But this is not yet the reality within the automotive industry today. The Society of Automotive Engineers has agreed on six levels of automation.

Tesla-AV-Chart 1400

Level 1 vehicles simply need to automate one part of driving, such as maintaining a set speed which can be achieved with cruise control. Level 2 vehicles must be able to assist with two aspects of driving, this is typically satisfied with adaptive cruise control and lane-keep assist systems.

Tesla Autopilot is actually only a level 2 system; in other words, it is not a self-driving car, and a human always needs to pay attention to the road. The problem for Tesla, IDTechEx says, is that its system has been “catastrophically over-marketed and oversold.”

The group says Musk has been talking about the “Full Self Driving” upgrade on Tesla vehicles since 2018, and with multiple revisions, upgrades and hype cycles since then, the group believes some confused customers will think they have bought a self-driving autonomous vehicle when they haven’t.

Another part of the problem is in Tesla’s camera-only sensor suite. While other manufacturers rely heavily on cameras, radars and LiDARs, Tesla is pursuing a camera-only approach and has even gone as far as removing the radar from Model 3 and Model Y vehicles (as of May 2021).

The justification is that humans can drive with their eyes: the same information a camera suite can capture. Therefore, a car will be able to drive with cameras alone. A camera suite also has better potential than a human driver as it provides a greater perspective around the vehicle, and thermal cameras can do a better job at night.

The problem is cameras do not have the same capabilities as radar. Although cameras can infer range and velocity through AI, radars can measure this information intrinsically and are almost completely unaffected by poor weather, darkness and direct sunlight, which are present challenges for a camera.

Tesla can certainly exceed human driving performance with a camera-only suite, but IDTechEx believes they have limited their potential by disregarding radar and have put themselves at a competitive disadvantage. Other manufacturers will also be bringing LiDAR into their ADAS sensor suites, which have some benefits over radar, but also some drawbacks.

Tesla-AV-Camera-Chart 1400

Radars and LiDARs can become very important at night when the camera systems are performing far below their peak potential. This is crucial for ADAS systems as most pedestrian fatalities happen at night. The NHTSA also noted that most of the incidents they are investigating involving Tesla’s autopilot systems happened in darker conditions.

IDTechEx says Tesla Autopilot and FSD are not bad systems; they are among the best ADAS systems on the market. It is unlikely that the U.S. government and the NHTSA will find anything untoward or dangerous within these systems. Instead, the group says, the problem lies entirely with a dangerous misinterpretation of the system’s capabilities.

For more information on this report, click here.

You May Also Like

BorgWarner announces additional eMotor business

The company says its HVH220 eMotor offers high power and torque density, enhanced efficiency and durability.


BorgWarner secured two high-voltage hairpin (HVH) eMotor business contracts with XPeng, a Chinese smart EV manufacturer, for use on two upcoming SUV models. The contracts include BorgWarner’s oil-cooled 800V eMotor systems, comprising stator and rotor components customized for the vehicles. Production is planned to start in 2025. BorgWarner says its HVH220 eMotor offers high power and torque density, enhanced efficiency and durability.

New Way Trucks, Hyzon showcase hydrogen FCEV refuse truck

This debut in the U.S. market follows February’s announcement of a joint development agreement between New Way and Hyzon.

Kia America breaks all-time monthly EV sales record in April

Three Kia utility vehicles each delivered the best April sales in their respective histories

DTNA expands EV use for logistics decarbonization

In line with its sustainability goals, DTNA said it aims to achieve carbon neutrality for all new products and services by 2039.

Legislation introduced to block Biden Administration EV mandates

A bipartisan coalition of Senators and House Representatives introduced Congressional Review Act legislation in the Senate and House.


Other Posts

Toyota prepares for new EV SUV production at Indiana facility

Toyota’s Indiana facility is home to more than 7,500 team members who assemble the Toyota Sienna, Highlander, Grand Highlander and Lexus TX.

Hybrid vehicles are poised to gain market share, Cloud Theory finds

This expectation comes after the Biden Administration slashed EV adoption targets from 67% to 35% by 2032.

Hybrid-EV-Market-Surge 1400
The social dynamics powering EV adoption

The best predictor of a person driving an EV is someone in their inner circle driving one first.

European hybrid vehicle demand is on the rise

JATO Dynamics said the drop in consumer confidence in EVs has sparked a surge in demand for hybrid electric vehicles (HEVs).